August 9, 2004

United we stand...

...in the unemployment line.

Last week, the Guy Chaddock, & Co. custom furniture manufacturing plant went out of business. The company started out as a family owned custom furniture supplier and grew into a nationwide distributor with over 20 showrooms and award winning designs. When their troubles began, they employed nearly 400 Bakersfield residents, mostly Hispanic workers who specialized in upholstery and carpentry skills.

Yo, wazzap holmes?

Three years ago, the United Farm Workers Union tried to get these employees to unite for the improvement of their working conditions. They claimed that employees were being forced to skip a number of scheduled breaks due to exceeding demand, and that the pay they were receiving for this work should be increased. Essentially, they asked the employees of Guy Chaddock, to form a union for the same reasons that every union does.

The problem is someone at the UFW didn't pay much attention to the people they were trying to help.

Over the course of the union push, the company laid off nearly half its labor force. They claim this was due to the increased legal fees incurred from battling the union. Early last month, the employees rejected the union proposal outright, choosing to keep the benefits and employment packages they already had. The UFW immediately filed a class action lawsuit against Chaddock, representing 5 employees who claimed they had been forced to skip a few lunch breaks to meet demand. This lawsuit was met with severe opposition from the current employees of Chaddock, but was unfortunately battled head-on by the owners of the furniture company.

Over time, Chaddock won the day in court but bankrupt the company fighting the UFW lawsuit.

Now, lets recap. The UFW gets a call that working conditions at the Guy Chaddock & Co., manufacturing plant are unacceptable. The UFW comes in and decides that changes need to be made -- so it's time for action. In spite of the employees claiming that they like the way things are, the UFW decides it knows better and fights for the "little guy" anyway. Since they know better than the people who work there, the UFW decides it's their responsibility to sue Chaddock when those foolish employees reject the union's proposal. The idea being that the employer will back down from the fight and give the union what it wants.

But that doesn't happen.

So who's to blame here? Is the United Farm Workers Union guilty of getting the remaining 200 employees fired by being indifferent to their needs? Is Guy Chaddock & Co., guilty of fighting a losing battle to the demise of their company? Did they both cornhole those 200+ people and their families for stupid reasons?

The answer is hard to find.

I'm not anti-union -- hell as an IT guy, I desperately want a nationwide union that actually has the strength to pressure Washington to stop outsourcing technical jobs to India. Estimates are somewhere around 400,000 IT and tech-related jobs shipped overseas for people who gladly work for pennies on your dollar.

The thing is, Union practices have become so negligent over the last decade that they're actually destroying the effectiveness of group labor initiatives. Groups like the UFW are there to help people -- so they should. Putting 400 people out of work because you think you're right isn't the way to do this. Sure, there were probably conditions for the majority of workers there (mostly Latino) that could have been improved.

But if you look close enough at what the UFW did here, it seems even more criminal. Guy Chaddock & Co. are bankrupt because they fought a legal case filed by a union that didn't even represent their employees. Some bleeding hearts came along, got told to take a hike, then took 5 former employees who claimed they didn't like their jobs and ran a 60+ year old, family run business, into the ground.

I'm sure the families of these people really appreciate standing in the welfare line. There's nothing like food stamps to make a hard working immigrants proud to be an American.

No comments: