A Constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage???
Oh, this is just too much people. We've gone off the deep end here. Take a deep breath and focus...that's it. Do you suddenly see the IMPORTANT STUFF that needs to be handled first? Maybe things like a worldwide AIDS epidemic, African tribal genocide at the hands of Muslim extremist, US service men and women dying in Iraq, and the newfound prosperity of Communist China could strike up a little more attention than this?
I mean seriously!
Ignoring the historical embarrassment this generation will have to endure by taking the Constitution of the United States and symbolically ball-point-penning the thing so we can keep gay people from getting hitched -- we're considering this mockery of our democracy in a time when there are more pressing issues at hand.
Constitutional amendments are what we reserve for historical changes to our society. This great republic stands on the truths of its Bill of Rights, and its Constitutional protections provided to its citizens. Changing these cornerstones of our ideals has to be done for the right reasons.
The President has pressed forward with this on a Federal level for his base constituency, who is outraged that homosexual and lesbian couples want to create laws in local State constitutions, affording them the same "rights and privileges" of heterosexual couples when it comes to marriage.
Why do they want to do this?
Well gay and lesbian groups repeat tons of rhetoric when asked on television, but when you finally get them to discuss their personal reasons you hear words like "social acceptance" and "equal rights". If you ask someone why they want this change, you'll find a very emotional response from that person. Words like these echo the words of civil rights leaders from 40 years ago. They echo the words of our founding fathers, in that they seek the equality of all men and women.
All this chest pounding and gnashing of teeth, for something they already have?!!
It's very important to them to fight for these rights in spite of the fact that a simple power of attorney can grant any gay or lesbian couple the same rights and privileges that a heterosexual couple have. Somehow, the American gay and lesbian community has convinced itself that getting the same marriage license from the State they live in will somehow make them equal in the hearts and minds of Americans abroad.
Right. I'm sure African American's would agree that being equal on paper means everyone treats you the same. Sure.
Lets get one thing straight. Everyone seems to have it wrong.
Gay & lesbian couples can already get married in this county!, Even if you lived in the most backwoods holler of Alabama, you can not be stopped from renting a space, getting a caterer, a band, tuxedos, or horrible bridesmaid dresses (or whatever), and a whole gaggle of your friends and loved ones together for a wedding.
There isn't a soul in this country that can tell you that you can't love someone forever, that you can't share your life with that person in a partnership that is established and recognized, and that you can't be afforded the rights of a spouse because of who you love. Regardless of how many times you have heard this, it's not true. Regardless of how many Priests & Ministers you have heard tell you that it's wrong, that they won't marry you in their church because it violates their religious laws, they can not stop you or interfere with your efforts to get married. You are free to love who you choose, how you choose.
The one thing you can not do is go down to a county courthouse and have two people of the same sex get the same marriage license that a couple of the opposite sex can.
Why?
Well mostly because we've built a system of checks and balances in our society for married couples. These include penalties and provisions, and generally institute a system of order for families and generation-based law. In other words, we have rules that allow husbands and wives to share property, responsibility, custody of family, and sharing of decisions regarding the care of these things -- even after death.
We also have this little thing called "Power of Attorney" which grants someone who isn't listed on a marriage or birth certificate the power to be involved with all of these rules we've established, and this is recognized by the court. This is recognized in banks, hospitals, schools, you name it. Power of attorney is actually even more specific than the contract of marriage when it comes to the boundaries and guidelines of what control one person can impose on another.
It's like a prenup for your life.
We've also established this system because yes, we live in a country where people of the opposite sex have controlled the laws and cultural biases. Yes, we live in a heterosexual country that has gay and lesbians living in it. What's the answer to acceptance?
You establish what makes us different.
Q) What is the difference between a gay heterosexual Caucasian male, 26 years old, protestant, Information Technology professional -- and heterosexual Caucasian male, 26 years old, protestant, Information Technology professional?
A) Their behavior. One sleeps with men, the other sleeps with women (if he's lucky, and keeps the Star Wars referenced to a minimum while on a date)
So, once you establish the difference between a gay or straight person, where do you establish homosexuality as a condition of existence that requires Federal protection under the provisions of the Constitution? Why does a behavior that an American engages in change his or her existence in the eyes of the United States Government?
Does religion fit into this category? Do we protect a persons right to worship a god they choose (technically a behavior) as much as we do a persons right so have sex with whom they choose?
Of course we do. That's why its not illegal to be gay.
You might ask why don't we change the laws to recognize the love of gay and lesbian couples on the same marriage certificate as heterosexual couples? So what about all these social rules and regulations our banks and schools have come accustomed to. We don't change a law of social inequality because its inconvenient?! That doesn't sound American.
Well, it might not sound American but the problem isn't recognizing love on a piece of paper. A marriage certificate doesn't imply love. It establishes the couple the right to be bound to an agreement imposed by a person with granted powers of the State. In other words it allows two people to enter into a contract with rules. A power of attorney certificate is the exact same thing. It allows two parties to enter into a contract with rules, imposed by an authority of the Sate.
What’s the difference, and why should this be accepted as an alternative to allowing gay and lesbian couples to use the same marriage certificates? The difference is in their application. If you use both instances of marriage with the same certificate, you get an extremely slippery slope of legal precedents that only spell trouble.
Just try to unravel the invasion of privacy and civil liberties issues you'll tangle up when insurance companies try to force you to prove that the guy you brought into your medical coverage policy, is actually your domestic partner? Does living together imply domestic partnership? If so, a roommate you kick out after only a week can technically have half your stuff upon dissolution of that domestic partnership.
The people who want to change the Constitution have two sides they sit on when it comes to english. One wants it to say "a union between two persons" and the other wants it to say "a union between a man and a woman". There's a really big snafu riding under the radar, and I've only heard a few legal analysts really touch on it.
You make a Constitutional amendment saying marriage is a union between two people, gay or straight, and you open the door for people to challenge the legality of a union being ONLY between two people. Polygamy is an accepted form of marriage around the world, however it's been fought tooth and nail in the U.S. for years. And hell, don't put "persons" or "people" in the constitution or someone could challenge the legality of forcing Americans to only marry someone outside their immediate family.
You think this stuff is far fetched and way outside the scope of reality? Pick up a yellow pages and call a lawyer. Ask that lawyer about precedence and what other lawyers like himself like to do once someone has set precedence in a court of law. It's called the slippery slope. Give them an inch, they'll take a mile. We live in a litigious society that works on loopholes and what-if's. That's why we keep the Constitution vague, and only allow the Supreme Court to handle the interpretation of it.
With regards to insurance fraud, what are they gonna do? Force us to kiss or have sex in front of an insurance agent to prove that we're gay? No of course not. That's outside the scope of reality because lawmakers can not find a way to establish being gay without invasion of privacy. It's been tried, even by liberal lawmakers -- and it fails each time.
That’s right, remember "Don't ask, don't tell?"
The reason William Jefferson Clinton, the 42nd President of the United States, (and the first chief executive who cared about gay rights) couldn't get the military to change its policies on homosexuality any more than that "chestnut", wasn't entirely because the military is a hard-knocks fraternity full of homophobic generals.
It's because they suddenly found this monolith of civil liberties standing in their way. How do you establish a behavior that includes and excludes a person from certain groups that have been afforded special Constitutional provisions? How do you do this, without infringing upon their right to privacy?
i.e. How can you tell if a guy is really gay without stepping all over his rights?
The answer is you can't. It's a behavior. Behavior can not be mandated and legislated that way. This is why we have power of attorney and marriage certificates. One works for straight couples, and one works for gay couples because they engage in different behavior. Sure, they might be the same skin color, same socio-economic group, same whatever. They're human and that's all that matters in the eyes of the US Government.
The difference is their behavior, and because of that they establish the rights afforded to married couples differently. Both straight and gay couples can be married, and share the same rights and privileges. Exactly the same. The only difference is that they get a different slip of paper at the courthouse when they want to get hitched.
It's almost too simple to be true. Just educate the gay community about the proper power of attorney rights and don't push for changes in State, or National Constitutions. The gay folks stay gay, the religious folks stay religious, and everyone goes back to blowing the hell out of Muslim whackjobs.
Ahhh, the good ole days.
July 13, 2004
Fairytale wedding...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

1 comment:
4 years ago, I was almost right....but so wrong. Still the best argument I've heard in opposition to gay marriage however. lol.
Post a Comment